Power struggle at work: what is really going on and how do you break the cycle?
Power struggles at work can arise from clashing egos, rivalry, or people seeking to maintain their influence. However, unclear responsibilities, conflicting interests, or past frustrations can also cause tension over control. Sometimes these factors reinforce each other. How do you recognize what is really going on, why does the struggle persist, and what helps to break the cycle?
The decision has been made. Yet nothing changes. During the meeting, it was agreed that tasks would be distributed differently from now on. A week later, it turns out that some colleagues are still working in the old way.
Didn't we agree that we would do this differently?
I already indicated back then why this doesn't work for us.
But then surely you can't just keep sticking to your own plan?
During the next meeting, the discussion is reopened. One colleague believes that agreements are apparently worthless. The other feels overlooked and feels that his objections are not being taken seriously. Meanwhile, conversations are taking place outside the meeting. Colleagues seek support for their position. Others prefer to remain aloof.
By now, it is no longer just about the division of tasks. It is also about who influences decisions, whose judgment carries the most weight, and who ultimately determines what happens. These types of situations occur within management teams, partnerships, regular teams, and between departments.
How do you recognize a power struggle at work?
A power struggle arises when people or groups compete with one another for influence, control, position, or resources. This can be very visible, for example, when two management team members constantly try to outdo each other. However, power struggles can also unfold more subtly.
An experienced colleague believes that his opinion should carry more weight because he has been working within the organization for twenty years. Another believes that everyone deserves an equal voice.
Or two departments hold each other responsible for problems and try to convince management that they are right.
Experience and expertise may, of course, carry weight in substantive considerations. It becomes problematic when someone automatically claims more say or gives others less leeway based on that.
Other signs include decisions that are consistently blocked, seeking allies, selectively sharing information, or agreements that are deliberately undermined. An important characteristic is that mutual power dynamics increasingly determine what is discussed, decided, and implemented.
However, not every critical stance or delayed decision points to a power struggle. For that, it must also become clear what is causing the behavior.
Where does the power struggle come from?
Research into power, status, and conflicts within teams shows that various factors can play a role.
Threatened influence or autonomy. A reorganization, a new manager, or a changing division of tasks can put existing relationships under pressure. Someone who has been making decisions independently for years suddenly has to coordinate. What is a logical change to others can be perceived as a loss of influence. Research shows that threat and uncertainty can intensify power struggles under certain circumstances [1].
Recognition and status. Some professionals feel that their experience, expertise, or contribution is not sufficiently appreciated. Others, however, try to secure an equal position. Research into status conflicts shows that the struggle for prestige and position can harm information exchange and team performance [2].
Conflicting interests. Sales wants to make commitments to customers faster, while Operations must monitor feasibility and quality. Both departments defend a legitimate interest, but can find themselves at odds when the joint result fades into the background.
Personal rivalry and power ambitions. Sometimes people consciously try to increase their influence or limit that of others. They seek allies, seize authority, or try to block proposals from certain colleagues. Such power strategies are also described in the negotiation literature [3].
The struggle for influence can also arise within partnerships and equal teams. After all, formal equality does not mean that everyone has the same informal power.
When it is unclear how decisions are made, the difference between formal authority and actual influence can cause additional tension.
Not everything that looks like a power struggle is a power struggle.
Sometimes it seems as if colleagues are vying for influence, while the main cause lies in the organizational structure.
Suppose that two managers believe they are responsible for the same decision.
One takes the initiative, while the other feels passed over.
What feels like taking ownership to one person, another experiences as exceeding authority.
Both may be acting out of their own sense of responsibility, while the roles and mandate are insufficiently clear. What appears to be a personal power struggle may in reality be an organizational problem.
Conflicting objectives or unclear decision-making rules can also cause such tension. If this is not recognized, frustrations and mistrust can accumulate. As a result, an initial organizational problem can eventually escalate into an actual power struggle.
What sustains a power struggle?
A power struggle can reinforce itself. Someone feels unheard and starts defending their point of view more emphatically. The other person perceives this as dominant behavior and offers more resistance. In response, the first colleague tries to gather support. The other person feels excluded and does the same.
The behavior with which one person tries to protect their position actually gives the other reason to defend their own position. Previous disappointments and damaged trust can reinforce this. Comments are more readily interpreted as criticism or obstruction. Gradually, the discussion shifts from the original interests to who is right and ultimately who can enforce their will. This is also described as the shift between interests, rights, and power [4].
The entire team can become involved as a result. Colleagues take sides, withdraw, or speak up less. Meetings last longer, decisions are reconsidered, and colleagues spend increasingly more time defending their position.
Meanwhile, important issues remain unresolved and agreements are not being adequately implemented. What began as a difference of opinion between a few individuals is now hindering the collaboration of the entire team.
How do you break out of a power struggle?
When a power struggle keeps recurring, the tendency is often to resume dialogue. However, when people deliberately undermine each other's influence, trust is severely damaged, or responsibilities are unclear, a good conversation alone is not sufficient. The approach must address what is causing and perpetuating the conflict.
1. Investigate what is really going on
Is it a matter of personal rivalry, threatened influence, conflicting interests, or unclear responsibilities? Who is involved? Which behaviors exacerbate the tension? And what role does the organizational structure play? Distinguish between facts, interpretations, and possible motives. A good analysis prevents an organizational problem from being treated as a personal conflict, but also ensures that deliberately undermining behavior is not explained solely by miscommunication.
2. Reduce tension and open for discussion regarding interests
When people are at odds, it makes little sense to immediately discuss the same subject again. First, investigate the concerns, expectations, and interests underlying their positions. Behind 'I do not agree,' for example, lies the concern that someone will be held responsible for results over which they have insufficient influence. Acknowledging those interests does not mean that every position must be adopted or that undesirable behavior is condoned.
It helps to understand why someone is holding on to their position and where there is room for a solution.
3. Clarify powers and decision-making
Who has what mandate? How are different interests weighed? Who ultimately makes the decision, and what is expected of those involved afterwards? Clear agreements on this are important, especially within equal teams.
Equality does not mean that everyone always gets their way. There is a difference between being seriously heard, having the right of consent, and being responsible for implementation. Research into procedural justice shows that the way decisions are made influences how people respond to them [5]. A careful decision-making process can support acceptance, even when not everyone agrees on the substance.
4. Set boundaries for power behavior and hold each other accountable
When someone systematically undermines decisions, excludes colleagues, or uses their position to pressure others, this behavior must be explicitly discussed.
Specify concretely what behavior is unacceptable, what effect it has on cooperation, and what is expected in the future. For example: objections may be raised, but once decisions are made, they must be implemented according to the agreements made. Anyone wishing to reconsider a decision must do so via the agreed procedure. Supervisors or other authorized persons must monitor this and intervene when agreements are repeatedly violated. Not every power struggle can be resolved by the parties involved themselves. In cases of serious intimidation, abuse of power, or transgressive behavior, a formal intervention or independent investigation may be necessary [6].
5. Change the behavior and ensure the agreements are adhered to
Discuss how colleagues will handle differences of opinion from now on.
How are objections discussed? How do those involved prevent decisions from being fought out again outside of the consultation? And who is responsible for the follow-up?
Research into conflict management within teams underscores the importance of clear agreements regarding decision-making and division of labor [7]. After an agreed period, assess whether the collaboration actually changes. Are decisions implemented? Do colleagues address each other directly? And is it possible to discuss differences without falling back into the same patterns?
From power struggle to shared responsibility
Breaking a power struggle does not mean that people have to give up their opinions or that differences disappear. It means that influence, responsibilities, and personal interests no longer stand in the way of joint decision-making. Sometimes this requires restoring trust and improving communication. Sometimes roles and powers need to be clarified. And sometimes deliberate power behavior needs to be limited.
Not every power struggle calls for the same solution. Only when it is clear what is causing and perpetuating the tension can targeted work be done to restore cooperation.
This requires attention to awareness, organizational structure, and communication.
Synergizing | Pace Synergy
With Synergizing, I guide teams in opening up tensions, improving collaboration, and making clear agreements. I combine analysis, independent facilitation, communication training, and live communication advice. In this way, teams work on their own issues while simultaneously learning to conduct difficult conversations increasingly independently and constructively.
Do the same discussions keep recurring, are decisions inadequately implemented, or are colleagues increasingly at odds with each other?
References and sources
[1] Van Bunderen, L., Greer, L. L. & Van Knippenberg, D. (2018). When Interteam Conflict Spirals into Intrateam Power Struggles: The Pivotal Role of Team Power Structures. Academy of Management Journal, 61(3), 1100–1130.
[2] Bendersky, C. & Hays, N. A. (2012). Status Conflict in Groups. Organization Science, 23(2), 323–340. Full published article (PDF).
[3] Shonk, K. (2020). Coping with Difficult Coworkers. Program on Negotiation, Harvard Law School. Practitioner article drawing on insights from Deborah Kolb and Judith Williams regarding power and influence in professional relationships.
[4] Ury, W. L., Brett, J. M. & Goldberg, S. B. (1988). Designing an Effective Dispute Resolution System. Negotiation Journal, 4(4), 413–431.
[5] Brockner, J. & Wiesenfeld, B. M. (1996). An Integrative Framework for Explaining Reactions to Decisions: Interactive Effects of Outcomes and Procedures. Psychological Bulletin, 120(2), 189–208. Full published article (PDF).
[6] CIPD (2025). Mediation at Work. Professional guidance on the applications and limitations of workplace mediation, including situations in which a formal procedure may be more appropriate.
[7] Behfar, K. J., Peterson, R. S., Mannix, E. A. & Trochim, W. M. K. (2008). The Critical Role of Conflict Resolution in Teams: A Close Look at the Links Between Conflict Type, Conflict Management Strategies, and Team Outcomes.Journal of Applied Psychology, 93(1), 170–188. Full published article (PDF).
Want to read more about specific themes?

